Tanner Scott: The Dodgers' Secret Weapon or a Risky Gamble?

The Los Angeles Dodgers, perennial contenders for the National League West division title, have been searching for that extra edge to take their franchise to the next level. With a robust farm system and savvy front office, the Dodgers have consistently identified and developed top talent. However, one player has generated immense buzz this offseason: Tanner Scott, the relief pitcher with a dubious past and an uncertain future.

Scott, 28, comes to the Dodgers via a trade with the Cleveland Indians, sending Luis Garrido and Donovan Casey to the Indians in exchange for the highly touted reliever. This move has left fans and analysts alike questioning the Dodgers' decision-making process. Is Scott a much-needed injection of talent or a costly gamble?

To answer this question, it's essential to delve into Scott's past and evaluate his potential on the field.

Understanding Tanner Scott's Background

2019's Troubling Year

Tanner Scott's 2019 season was one of turmoil. He began the year with the New York Yankees, posting a 3.38 ERA in 31.1 innings pitched before being demoted to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. This decline in performance can be attributed to an increased workload, with Scott appearing in at least 50 games for the first time in his career.

Missed Time and Conditioning Concerns

The Pittsburgh Pirates picked up Scott off waivers in July, and his time with the team was marked by inconsistency. He appeared in 22 games, posting a 4.91 ERA, before being demoted to the minors in September. The Pirates ultimately released Scott in October.

Scott's 2019 season was also marred by reports of him being overweight and struggling with conditioning. A scouting report from Baseball America noted that Scott's weight was a significant concern, as it could impact his velocity and overall effectiveness on the mound.

Is Scott Worth the Risk?

Despite his tumultuous past, Scott still possesses elite pitching mechanics and a impressive arsenal of pitches. His fastball sits in the mid-90s, and he can locate his secondary offerings with precision.

Some potential reasons for the Dodgers' interest in Scott include:

• Veteran presence: Scott's age and experience could provide a much-needed presence in the bullpen, particularly in situations where a pitcher needs to be trusted to shut down the opposing team.
• Workload management: With Scott's arm, the Dodgers could potentially limit his workload and avoid the long-term damage that comes with it.
• Cost-effective: Compared to some of the top relief pitchers available, Scott's contract is relatively inexpensive, making him an attractive option for the Dodgers.

However, there are also valid concerns about Scott's potential:

• Injury history: Scott has a history of injuries, including a shoulder strain in 2019 that landed him on the injured list.
• Conditioning concerns: If Scott's weight and conditioning continue to be an issue, it could impact his performance and overall effectiveness.
• Questionable work ethic: Reports of Scott's weight and conditioning issues raise concerns about his work ethic and commitment to his craft.

Evaluating Scott's Potential with the Dodgers

Reasons to be Optimistic

1. Established veteran presence: Scott's age and experience provide a level of comfort for the Dodgers, particularly in high-pressure situations.
2. Unique skillset: Scott's combination of velocity and secondary offerings makes him an intriguing addition to the Dodgers' bullpen.
3. Cost-effective: Compared to some of the top relief pitchers available, Scott's contract is relatively inexpensive, making him an attractive option.

Reasons to be Cautious

1. Injury history: Scott's history of injuries raises concerns about his long-term health and effectiveness.
2. Conditioning concerns: If Scott's weight and conditioning continue to be an issue, it could impact his performance and overall effectiveness.
3. Questionable work ethic: Reports of Scott's weight and conditioning issues raise concerns about his commitment to his craft.

What's Next for Tanner Scott

As Scott joins the Dodgers, fans will be eager to see how he adapts to the team's high-pressure environment. With a talented supporting cast and a relatively easy schedule to start the season, the Dodgers' relief corps will face a range of situations that will test Scott's skills.

Breaking Down the Dodgers' Relievers

1. Closer- By-in-Position: Who will close games, and when?
2. Setup Men: Who will set up the closer, and what role will they play?
3. Long Relief: Who will handle the long-relief roles, and what will be their focus?

Ultimately, the Dodgers' decision to acquire Scott will be vindicated or exposed in the coming weeks and months. As fans and analysts watch Scott's progress, one thing is clear: the Dodgers have made a bold move, and the results will speak for themselves.